Dual-Band Monitoring Keeps Trains Running in Winter

Dual-Band Monitoring Keeps Trains Running in Winter


Railways must run around the clock, seven days a week – interruptions for subsystem or component failures cannot occur. A single disabled part in the wrong place and at the wrong time can paralyze entire rail branches and cause delays that can last for hours. In the winter, the moving parts of a rail network can fail because of snow and ice accumulation, which typically occurs between stock rails and switch point blades.

To keep trains running under all weather conditions, railroad companies use snow and ice removal equipment: air blowers designed to keep switches clear of snow and ice, self-propelled plows tailored for quick clearing of the heaviest of snow accumulation, and plow attachments that can be added to existing equipment. A static solution is the use of heater elements close to the switch points so that the rail temperature in those areas can be kept above freezing. These heaters can be powered by gas, electricity or geothermal energy.

Switch-point heating raises the temperature of rails to melt ice or snow before it can accumulate between the point blade and the stock rail. Any ice keeping the switch mechanism from working properly is removed as well. Three parts must be heated: stock rail, switch blade and switch mechanism. In simple cases, the heating elements are easily mounted on the shoulder of the inner side of the stock rail. The radiated heat combined with the conducted heat in the rails keeps the area between stock rail and switch blade free from ice and snow.

Switch-mechanism heaters can also keep locks and linkage parts free of snow and ice. They consist of a steel heat conducting plate with a heating element similar to the rail-heating element. They are placed in the switch-mechanism duct.

Figure 1 shows some switch heaters used by LIRR (the Long Island Railroad) in Queens, N.Y., during a winter storm. These gas-powered heaters could keep the rail transport area open even at an electric power failure.

Supervision of switch-point heating

To ensure reliable operation throughout the winter, it is important to get instant error messages about failed or missing heating elements in critical switches. One solution is the use of two temperature sensors on each switch. The hot-rail sensor is normally mounted on the shoulder of the heated rail, whereas the cold-rail sensor is often mounted under the rail, apart from the heated zone. This will prevent sunshine interfering with a correct cold-rail temperature reading.

Another way to ensure proper operation is to observe the switches from above instead from below. From a bird’s-eye view, the heated switches look like hot spots on the ground. They are easily detected by infrared cameras in the LWIR (long wave infrared) wavelength range between 8 and 14 µm.

LWIR cameras for this application are based on uncooled microbolometer arrays that, unlike photon detectors, act as energy detectors. Microbolometers consist of thermally isolated microbridges, with a temperature-sensitive material added on top. The temperature-sensitive material can be V2O5, a-Si or poly-SiGe. The microbridges are micromachined directly on the surface of the circuits. This establishes a compromise between a good electrical contact, needed to read out the detector element, and a poor thermal contact, which prevents thermal leakage of the absorbed radiation.

Figure 2 shows a stationary monitoring solution called GeoCamPro. It was developed by the Dutch company Secure in Air for ProRail, which serves as an installation and maintenance company for the Nederlandse Spoorwegen railway company.

In this setup, a very precise PTZ camera platform is mounted on the roof of a building about 150 ft high. The platform's rotation tolerance is very tight, not exceeding 0.01°. The building is located in the vicinity of the railway yard nearby a station, where most of the switches and heaters are located. The scene therefore can be easily monitored from this elevated position (Figure 3).

The platform is equipped with two cameras to enable a dual-band view of the scene: a high-resolution thermal camera Xenics Gobi-640-GigE (Figure 4a) with a 100-mm lens covering the LWIR range, plus a daylight camera with a zoom lens of 500-mm focal length. This camera features a 640 x 480 pixel image resolution based on a microbolometer array with a 17-µm pitch, which requires no cooling. This advanced thermal sensor safely detects very small temperature differences down to 50 mK and delivers them as thermal images at up to 50 frames per second. Powerful image processing on board the camera provides high-quality images with good contrast. It also can self-adjust automatically. This way, the camera will adapt contrast and brightness automatically according to the scene, and the dynamic range is optimized for various environmental conditions.

The camera is optimized for demanding user requirements. Its design accommodates reduced volume, weight and power consumption, opening a new range of applications for LWIR sensors. Optimization of the implemented hardware and smart use of the FPGA (field programmable gate array) have significantly lowered power consumption, so that the camera now can be powered via Gigabit Ethernet connection. This lowers installation cost, particularly for multiple cameras in a network, raises reliability and allows easy integration of the camera in security environments.

The system’s PTZ platform with visible-realm and LWIR cameras scans up to 50 objects per minute at a maximum range of 2000 ft. The on-board thermography calibration of the thermal camera covers the standard range from -4 to 248 °F, which is sufficient for this application. Optionally available are thermography calibrations from 122 to 752 °F, 572 to 2192 °F, and up to 3632 °F for very advanced industrial applications.

Just as the railroad switches are affected by snow, sleet or ice, so is the surveillance equipment. Precautions were taken to withstand these severe weather conditions: When the temperature of the surveillance system falls to about 41 °F or below, an internal heater is initiated to heat the complete casing of the cameras. This is only necessary for de-icing the equipment; the LWIR camera itself is specified for a wide temperature range from -40 to 167 °F. To reduce the chance of snow or rain collecting on the camera windows, they are roofed by rain hoods. No raindrops on the windows were reported.

In this application, corrosion is also an important issue. The complete camera housing is filled with nitrogen gas at 1.5 X atmospheric pressure and features moisture absorption. Even under extremely cold conditions, moisture presence is virtually impossible, but even if this would be the case, it would immediately be absorbed.

Dual-band surveillance operation

The first step in setting up a dual-band surveillance is to establish a baseline picture as a reference for each important point or spot in the field: the switches, joints and other objects to be monitored. They are registered as symbols in a digital geographical map, which can be displayed by a smart geographical viewer. During operation, both cameras will continuously take pictures in the infrared and the visible range of every spot of a railway yard near a station, where most switches and heaters can be found.

Each picture is stored and compared to the one previously taken and to the baseline. This creates a film of every spot in the field with daylight and LWIR exposure. It can be viewed in quick motion to recognize differences and trends, and to reveal the cause of a detected problem.

When the LWIR camera detects a switch-gear problem, an alarm sounds (if the user so desires) and the problem spot is highlighted on the map. Now the operator can point and zoom the daylight camera to that point to investigate what is going wrong: Is there a mechanical problem or has ice gotten between the switch points?

The system works to a large extent autonomously, with a very low false-alarm rate, optimized by self-learning algorithms. When, for example, a heater doesn’t work at all, this represents a major problem. If it is working but not properly (only one of several heaters of the switch heater may not be operational) and there is no freezing temperature, this is just a case of concern. The user can decide, judging by the amount of data delivered, how to analyze and resolve this problem at later time.

Additional functions

Switch heaters are not the only sources of elevated temperatures in railway networks to be monitored by an LWIR camera. Such advanced systems also can help discover unauthorized persons walking between the rails, causing possible disturbances and delays for travelers, and can assist in the supervision of hot-boxes on passing trains (at least from one side).

The LWIR system can also be an important addition to regular procedures used on construction sites to deliver information about the progress of construction measures, possible damages, security breaches, waste, the status of fences and the proper closing of gates.


A few years ago Secure in Air has tested its deployment aboard a drone to monitor railroad switch heaters from the air. The LWIR camera (Figure 4a), a daylight camera and communication equipment were mounted as a payload (Figure 4b) on a self-built drone (Figure 4c) based on a Trex 600 with autopilot from MicroPilot. Mission time (Figure 4d) amounted to just a few minutes, but the system demonstrated the feasibility of dual-band monitoring of railroad switch heaters.


Meet the authors

Raf Vandersmissen is the CEO of sInfraRed (a subsidiary of Xenics of Belgium) in Singapore; email: raf.vandersmissen@sinfrared.com. Robert de Nes is the CEO of Secure in Air in Helmond/Eindhoven, The Netherlands; email: info@secureinair.nl



1. www.thelirrtoday.com/2014/02/switch-heaters.html.

2. www.progressiverailroading.com/mow/article/railroad-snow-plows-air-blowe....



Figure 1. LIRR switch heaters in Queens, N.Y., during a winter storm. Courtesy of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority Facebook/Patrick Cashin.


Figure 2. Dual-band image fusion on a PTZ platform GeoCamPro, which monitors switch heaters at a maximum range of 2000 ft.


Figure 3. (a) A group of switches. (b) An LWIR image of the same switches shows that their temperature is elevated.


Figure 4. An experimental setup for the IR monitoring of switch heating by drones: (a) high-resolution LWIR camera Gobi-640; (b) two cameras and communication equipment as payload of a drone; (c) drone take-off; and (d) inspection flight.

Thermal Imagers in mobile systems for Security & Safety Market

It was a challenge to produce a mobile system for border control in just 6 months, but with Xenics as a partner we could apply for this project.

Ivica Mijić, Audio-Video Trend