Thermal imaging for monitoring rolling element bearings

Thermal imaging for monitoring rolling element bearings

WRITTEN BY JAN VERMEIREN, XENICS
ORIGINAL PAPER PUBLISHED BY QIRT (2014)
AUTHORS OF THE ORIGINAL PAPER BY R. SCHULTZ, S. VERSTOCKT, M. LOCCUFIER, K. STOCKMAN and S. VAN HOECKE - GHENT UNIVERSITY

ABSTRACT
To be reliably operated off-shore wind turbines need an assured downtime and maintenance pattern to keep costs low. A monitoring project carried out by the authors uses an infrared (LWIR) thermal camera placed in the drive trains of such turbines and focusing on their spherical roller bearings. A bearing having an inner raceway fault shows a faster and higher temperature increase than a healthy bearing. Whereas vibrations tend to propagate through the drive train, temperature increase is a more local phenomenon. The article presents a methodology for analyzing such measurements based on a thermal camera for the detection, visualization and localization of faults. This makes it a promising tool in the condition monitoring of fully covered and sealed rolling element bearings in industrial applications.

Introduction
Short-termed maintenance of wind turbines on high seas is very expensive. Replacing faulty components can take months. Thus, early and reliable fault detection can avoid more expensive consequential damage, or even a complete failure leading to loss of production.

Due to their tribological nature gears and bearings are affected by wear and friction. Consequences include vibration, acoustic and heat emissions, which can be monitored by different sensor-based techniques.

The main cause of downtime are faults in the drive train, with bearing faults belonging to the major reliability issues, because bearings must deal with cyclic and transient loads as well as alignment problems. The majority of gearbox faults in wind turbines appear to originate in the bearings and propagate towards the gear teeth.

Vibrations and acoustic emissions propagate through the drive train structure, which can make fault localization difficult. It requires great expertise and detailed system models. Real-time oil analysis is usually limited to measuring oil quality and particle counts. To obtain more detailed information for identifying the faulty component and a fault classification requires an on-shore sample analysis, which itself can be costly regarding time and financing.

Most bearing faults result in increased temperature. This offers the opportunity of using thermal imaging for a real-time monitoring and localization. It also allows a spatial visualization of the heat propagation in the monitored areas. Increased temperature is usually a more local phenomenon, so thermal imaging can improve fault detection and complement the currently used condition monitoring techniques. A multiple-sensor approach combining classic techniques such as vibration analysis with thermal imaging is a promising alternative for early fault detection, on-line component identification and real-time fault classification.

Experimental Setup
The test setup was used for monitoring FAG 22205-E1-K spherical roller
bearings. These bearings consist of cylindrical rollers, which manage high
axial forces oscillating in both directions, as well as radial forces. They are designed to handle heavy loads such as in wind turbines. The close oscillation between rollers and raceways supports uniform stress distribution. The bearings are completely covered and sealed.

In this setup, the bearings were mounted within FAG SNV052-F-L plummer block housings. The shaft is a solid Cf53, made of hardened and ground steel, and has a diameter of 20 mm with an h6 tolerance rate.

Besides intact bearings, intentionally pre-damaged bearings were monitored as well. Pitting, as one of the most common faults with a variety of possible causes, was simulated by means of a milling machine. 

Each of these tests ran for one hour at a speed of 1,500 rotations per minute, which is standard for high-speed components in European wind turbine drive trains.

To monitor the setup, the Gobi-640-GigE, an uncooled long-wave infrared (LWIR) camera by Xenics, was used at 6.25 frames/sec. The thermocouples located behind the setup are to monitor the ambient temperature, which serves as reference for the data processing.

Methodology
Thermal measurements were performed for both healthy and faulty bearings. Before each measurement, the setup was cooled down to ambient temperature in order to receive a comparable starting situation and to understand the general heat-up process.

All bearings were monitored from various points of view. Our analysis is focusing on the camera location sideways of the setup. This allows the monitoring of both bearing housing and shaft. 

Because the bearing housing and the shaft exhibit different temperature characteristics and noise effects, reflections and regions of interests were selected and further analyzed. Both two-dimensional and three-dimensional surface plots were analyzed to determine the actual thermal characteristics of both healthy and faulty bearings as well as noise, to consequently support the
choice of meaningful regions of interest.

The upper housing is closest to the outer ring because of lower material thickness and is therefore selected as the first region of interest. The bottom part of the shaft next to the bearing housing is expected to show a heat increase based on both natural impacts such as shaft bending as well as bearing faults. Therefore it was selected as second region of interest.

To reduce the impact of environmental changes, all diagrams show the temperature relative to ambient temperature. In other words, the ambient temperature is subtracted from the absolute temperature.

Ambient temperature is measured by the thermocouples. Using relative temperatures instead of absolute temperatures yields consistent results
independent of ambient temperature. This procedure significantly reduces step effects in the trend graphs caused by camera calibration. It therefore improves the readability of the data.

For each bearing, four measurements were performed with the discussed camera location. Inner raceway faults consistently show higher temperatures than healthy bearings, as well as faster temperature increases. However, the difference of the maximum temperatures between both bearings at the end of each measurement varies. Therefore, average trends are created from four individual measurements for each bearing.

Furthermore, both the temperature gain and the time constants are discussed for these average trends. Relative temperature gain is the difference between the relative temperatures of the system in non-operating state, and after sixty minutes in the operating state. To get the time constants, the trend graphs of both the healthy bearing and the inner raceway fault are matched with first-order dynamics. The time constant of the system response is the time required by the step response to reach 63% of its final value.

Results
This methodology is applied to both healthy and faulty bearings. First, the surfaces of both bearing housing and shaft are analyzed to determine regions of interests for trend analysis.
Each of the presented surface plots displays the last image taken at the end of the corresponding measurement period of sixty minutes.

Frame-wise analysis of bearing housing
The non-uniform surface of the bearing housing leads to different temperature characteristics. The material of the upper housing is thinner and tends to a faster heat-increase than the bottom part. The screw visible in the upper center of the housing as well as the polished surface on top of the housing cause distinct drops in the measurements, making these regions unsuitable for further analysis. The central upper region of the housing is closest to the outer bearing ring because of thinner material and shows the highest temperatures. Therefore, this region is chosen for further analysis.

Both images of the healthy bearing and the bering with inner racewy show noise caused by reflection of light, the thermal measurements need to be carefully analyzed. For the inner raceway fault, higher temperatures are monitored as well as stronger heat propagation across the surface, which is indicated by the
more uniform color representation.

Frame-wise analysis of the shaft
The second region of interest is the shaft. Increased temperatures were encountered in the bottom right shaft next to the bearing housing. They represent the complete shaft part between bearing housing and mass
rotor for both healthy and faulty bearings.

The shaft shows a distinct heat increase next to the bearing housing for both healthy and faulty bearings. As the housing is sealed and the rotation of the shaft seems to provide a cooling effect, this heat increase only occurs in a small region. Central and upper shaft regions show lower temperatures and in fact no distinguishable heat increase for both healthy and faulty bearings. The peaks in the upper shaft are caused by light reflections. It is evident that the
locations of the reflections on the shaft are not fixed but slightly oscillating up and down.
Because of these characteristics, a further analysis of the shaft focuses on the heat increase in the bottom part next to the housing.

Trend analysis
The surface plots give insight in the temperature distribution in the regions of interest at a specific point in time, or more precise: after sixty minutes of system runtime. Whereas the region of interest at the housing shows a more uniform temperature distribution, the shaft is strongly affected by the light reflection. A significant heat increase is seen only in its bottom right
corner, next to the bearing housing.

However, a first trend analysis of the shaft did not permit a reliable distinction between healthy and faulty bearings. Therefore, the trend analysis focuses on the region of interest in the upper center of the housing. The central point of this region, which is not affected by light reflection, is selected for the following trend analysis.

The average relative temperature increases and step responses for the central point of the region of interest on the housing, independent of the ambient temperature.
Whereas the thermocouples indicate only small differences in the ambient temperature, the temperature of the housing differs for the various bearings. In particular, the temperature of an inner raceway fault increases faster than in the healthy bearing.

The inner raceway fault follows a first-order behavior straight from the beginning. The healthy bearing shows a more second-order behavior. Second-order behavior is approximated by a first-order model with dead time. The dead time defines the initial time required by the trend to show first-order behavior. In particular, a dead time of 48 seconds is determined for the healthy bearing.

The stronger temperature gain and faster heat increase in the bearing with
an inner raceway fault enable a distinction between healthy and faulty bearings. They also reveal the potential for fault detection by thermal imaging.

Conclusion
Fully covered and sealed rolling element bearings monitored by a thermal camera show different temperature increases in a healthy bearing and a bearing with inner raceway fault. The inner raceway fault leads to a faster and higher temperature increase of the housing. Whereas vibrations propagate through the drive train and fault localization requires high expertise, temperature increase is of a more local impact as can be seen in the temperature propagation from the housing towards the shaft. Thermal cameras are useful for visualizing as well as localizing faults as a promising tool for condition monitoring of wind turbine drive trains.

Contact us for more information

New Xeneth LabVIEW SDK

LabVIEW toolkit for Xenics cameras offers high-level examples as well as low-level VIs, making it easy for programmers to integrate Xenics cameras into their software applications written in LabVIEW

Jan Šíma, Business Development Manager, ELCOM, a.s.